Can a film peddle several topics - fight
against the politics in the sports industry, rip apart social class
distinctions, discuss casteism and make a valid criticism of male chauvinism,
female empowerment, all at the same time? Technically speaking, it is impossible
for any director to explore all these critical endeavours on one platform. In
an Atlee film, it is even scarier to give this ambitious project to a boy who
has a track record of mixing 7 swarangal and 7 raagams. So how does Bigil support
young women in self-actualizing their inner power - empower - to truly leapfrog
women’s empowerment?
Bigil, right from the trailer to its audio launch speeches,
screams female empowerment and that this film is a tribute to Singapenneys of our
society. I wonder if it is justified in the first half of the film that is
peppered with so much build-ups for Bigil who is a former state player and someone
who possesses cartoony body-language that is mandatory to pull the crowd aged
16 and below. There is a cute dance and stunt introduction, followed by a few more
fights in the first half. A romantic sequence is established.
But I have yet to know what Bigil does for a living as he is neither a football player nor a coach at this point of time. Like in every don film, how do they pay their bills? Like really, I am curious man! Sothuku enna thaan la pannreenga? There is a Baasha reference when Vijay’s friend, Kathir meets Vijay and he addresses Vijay as “Baasha Bhai”. We hear about Rayappan, Bigil’s father, in the flashback. Rayappan sings a MGR song. Ok, all the mass/commercial elements with the indication of “I-might-come-into-politics” are ticked. But what happened to the female empowering story that you promised, Atlee?
But I have yet to know what Bigil does for a living as he is neither a football player nor a coach at this point of time. Like in every don film, how do they pay their bills? Like really, I am curious man! Sothuku enna thaan la pannreenga? There is a Baasha reference when Vijay’s friend, Kathir meets Vijay and he addresses Vijay as “Baasha Bhai”. We hear about Rayappan, Bigil’s father, in the flashback. Rayappan sings a MGR song. Ok, all the mass/commercial elements with the indication of “I-might-come-into-politics” are ticked. But what happened to the female empowering story that you promised, Atlee?
If only Atlee, copied scene to scene from just one film (that is
SRK’s Chak De India. Atlee, just FYI, since you may not know such a film
exists), Bigil could have been a real treat. Because I quite enjoyed the 2nd
half. In fact, I was pleasantly surprised that Atlee managed to weave sensitive
and relevant topics in the second half. According to research, women’s
empowerment can be categorised in these 5 aspects-
-women’s sense of self-worth;
Pandiyamma tends to have a liking for food, is called out as
Gundamma by the hero who uses reverse psychology during a crucial match to fuel
a winning spirit in her. In other films, a girl probably could have been answered
with a tearful response to that. But here, Pandiyamma’s first reaction is to fiercely
roar at Vijay,
“Don’t you ever call me that?”
Even though critics point out the paradox in this scene as it can be labelled as ‘body-shaming’, I love how she retaliated instead of a soft approach- to cry. And that is where I believe Atlee has scored a few brownie points.
Even though critics point out the paradox in this scene as it can be labelled as ‘body-shaming’, I love how she retaliated instead of a soft approach- to cry. And that is where I believe Atlee has scored a few brownie points.
-their right to have and to
determine choices;
One of the players in the women’s national team is married and her
husband becomes a hindrance to her football dreams. Nayanthara and Vijay
intervene and explain to the husband from an orthodox family about the choices
a woman has and the liberty she can take.
-their right to have access to opportunities and resources;
Atlee leaves a blank in this segment
-their right to have power to control their own lives, both within
and outside the home;
A story of an acid-attack survivor makes quite a mark. The way she
deals with punishing the attacker, after several years, speaks volume. Even
though I completely disagree with that kind of a solution, I love that there is
space given in the story to tell us how women can take control of their lives.
-and their ability to influence the direction of social change to
create a more just social and economic order, nationally and internationally.
Another blank by Atlee.
Having ticked almost 3 out of the 5 boxes, this is indeed quite an
achievement in a film like Bigil. But there is another problem. All these
issues are single-handedly solved by Bigil’s intervention or lecturing. On top
of being a coach, he basically goes around as a life consultant and a
motivational speaker which may again questions the vision of how they want to
show the power of women.
In a film that speaks about giving respect for women, there is a
stalking scene where Vijay drives his bike straight into Nayanthara’s college
classroom and asks her to come out of the class to settle for a trophy that she
damaged the day before. Instantly, Vijay who has only met her twice, utters, “cup-a
aparam kodu. ippothiku enaku company kodu.”
Is this supposed to be considered as a flirtatious pick up line exchanged
between 2 grown up adults?
And Yogi Babu goes, “Aval thaan ivana ushaaar pannitaa”
Ushaar pannitaa? So much so for Singappenney, Mavaney!
Ushaar pannitaa? So much so for Singappenney, Mavaney!
Despite all these flaws and some clichéd regressive lines/scenes,
Atlee equalises each drawback with a bicycle-kick goal! Just like how the
colour of jersey worn by the girls during the football matches keep changing
between red and orange because of the poor colour editing and VFX team, the highlights
and lows keep changing from scene to scene in the narrative.
Being an ardent Vijay fan, let me say this- Vijay's strength, other than his young genes, is in subtle acting in certain emotional scenes. There is a scene where he listens to the story of how the girl was brutally attacked by a stalker and the trauma she went through after suffering from the acid burns. With hands clasped together, there is a drop of tear trickling down his right cheek. Very well-emoted scene that was!
If you wonder why Vembu needs a short-hair wig or why Nayanthara
has super long manicured nails being a physiotherapist, remember the kutti
story by Vijay during the audio launch- the story about how a boy who sells
flower was hired to work in a pattasu factory.
If you forgive those mistakes, then believe what Atlee said in the
same function, “This is my best writing film thus far”
Comments
Post a Comment