Lewd. Offensive. Salacious.
How else can I describe the song from the recent film Thirunaal? A movie which
I happened to watch it because I, sometimes, love torturing myself in the most brutal
way possible. I wanted to simply write it off as “thirunaal- en vazhakaiye veruthu
oru naal” ( A day which I regretted the most) However, what shocked me, was
this ‘Thittathe’ song from the yawn-inducing movie which has all capacity to
make your IQ level go down the drain.
The context of the song- A woman. A woman dressed in an attire which was quite obvious that she appeared in that scene, all ready for an item number. She alighted from the autorickshaw, walked towards a group of rowdies. She sat beside them, wiped off her perspiration on her forehead with the saree pallu. One of the senior rowdies asked in the most condescending manner, “ai! do you want beer?”
She, “not in the mood.”
He, “ cigarette?”
she, “not in the mood.”
And just because of that, he got pissed off and commanded her, “Hey atleast sing a song, thevudiya!”
*thevidya- prostitute.
The context of the song- A woman. A woman dressed in an attire which was quite obvious that she appeared in that scene, all ready for an item number. She alighted from the autorickshaw, walked towards a group of rowdies. She sat beside them, wiped off her perspiration on her forehead with the saree pallu. One of the senior rowdies asked in the most condescending manner, “ai! do you want beer?”
She, “not in the mood.”
He, “ cigarette?”
she, “not in the mood.”
And just because of that, he got pissed off and commanded her, “Hey atleast sing a song, thevudiya!”
*thevidya- prostitute.
And she got up enthusiastically, started singing, beaming with delight about how she should be scolded instead of ‘thevudiya’
and the end verse has been penned this way:
Vaadiyanum(a term used to address a lady in a rude manner)
Podiyanum(a term used to address a lady in a rude manner)
Podiyanum(a term used to address a lady in a rude manner)
Kediyunum (cunning)
Thittu
Makkunum (brainless)
Kiriki Inum Araki(demon)
Inum Thittu
Vaadiyanum Podiyanum Kediyunum Thittu
Makku Inum Kiriki Inum Araki Inum Thittu
Ellam Ṣọlli Thittu Eppadi Vena Thittu (Reprimand me in any
way you want)
Ellam Ṣọlli Thittu Eppadi Vena Thittu
Muttalunum (stupid)
Mandu (moron)
Inum
Madachi(unintelligent)
Inum Thittu
Niruthi Kọnjam Nithanachi Ṣiriki Inum Thittu (Pause, think
of a better word, why not call me bitch?)
Ippadi Ellam Azhagu Vartha Iruka Iruka (Look, there are so
many other beautiful words to address me)
Ena Ippadi yEnda Thitti Puta Manaṣu Valika Ṣuruka (Why did
you call me prostitute then?)
Previously, we had songs sung by the heroes or the comedians
degrading women to dictate what a woman should wear, eat, say and do
constantly. It was demeaning and offensive enough to have created many
controversies and have kept women in an unsafe environment. But here, when the
woman herself is singing and inviting men to objectify her, this is completely
dehumanizing on many levels.
A recent United Nations sponsored study conducted by a
leading California-based journalism school, Indian films topped the chart in
sexualised portrayal of women onscreen. The study also states that 35% of
female characters in Indian movies are shown with some nudity, the study
reports. That's not all. This isn't the first time stereotyping and
sexualisation of women in Indian cinema have been talked about; however, the
fact that it has ranked so high on an international survey has come as a surprise.
It’s a topic that’s consistently been debated, and we’re left wondering why
there continues to be an abundance of over-sexualized, sexist and misogynistic portrayals
in tamil cinema.
Where did all this start?
Erotic Tamil Literature. Sex, love-making, describing women’s body parts are explicitly been stated in many of the Tamil literature books.
Erotic Tamil Literature. Sex, love-making, describing women’s body parts are explicitly been stated in many of the Tamil literature books.
In Silapathigaram, Kovalan has moved around with Madhavi for
quite a while. They are on the shores of the beach, singing for each other .
Here Kovalan sings some songs for Madhavi and she plays the harp. Koval is in
mood and sings erotic songs. He literally makes suggestion “why are we wasting
time? It is plain boring here and lets go have sex (Because in the next chapter
he gets bored with Madhavi and leaves her!). Kovalan sings lot of songs which
are erotic and sometimes indecent too.
Your Elders do their fishing in the sea ,
and live by killing blameless creatures there.
You do your fishing in my heart,
and live by causing me to die.
Oh pray ,be careful not to break
your waist,too frail to bear the weight
of young breast growing opulent !
Your father kills the buoyant fish
caught in the ambush of his net.
But you delight to kill all living things
caught by your lovely eyes’ most deadly snare.
Oh pray, be careful not to break
your waist, thinner than thunderbolts,
for it may yield beneath its load
of heavy breasts and strings of pearls!
Your brothers in their swift canoe
go hunting creatures that have done no harm.
But you kill with the arched bow of your brows;
your fame increases with the grief you cause.
Oh pray, protect the slimness of your waist,
that’s growing strong beneath the burden of your breast.
So, imagine a poet who have read many of these Tamil
literature books becomes a Tamil song lyricist and we get songs like
Aa Tøuch'chu Tøuch'chu Tøuch'chu Tøuch'chu
Aa Tøuch'chu Tøuch'chu Tøuch'chu Tøuch'chu
Ènna Tøuch Me..
Oah Kichu Kichu Kichu Kichu Ènna Kichu Me..
7 Maniku Maela Naanum Inbha Lachumi
-
- -Stylu Stylu thaan From Baasha. Penned by
Vairamuthu
Many composers are very particular
about using dummy words or words to attract kids because a song’s popularity attains its peak when kids start mimicking them. And “touch-u touch-u, kich-u
kich-u” sound very much like a kindergarten rhyme and then it ends off with the
woman singing, “I become your fantasy after 7pm.”
Woah. Woah. Where did that come from?
Woah. Woah. Where did that come from?
Objectification of women is rampant in many movies whether
it's "eyepopping skin show" or innuendo-laden lyrics, which are all
about female sexuality, the references are overwhelming. The objectification
and sexualisation aren’t restricted to clothes alone. The manner in which a
female character is addressed in some of the dialogues and songs clearly
suggest references to her sexuality and how the man is going to exploit it.
It's akin to raping a woman with words.
Yen Iduppu Orama Irukuthaiya Kaarama
(there is something spicy near my hip)
Kandu Neeyum Pudichitta Èduthakkaiya Thaaralama
(if you can
find it, take as much as you want)
- Kalyanam thaan From Saamy. Penned by Snehan
- Kalyanam thaan From Saamy. Penned by Snehan
Ini kurayuttum thiruvilaku. (Let the flame flicker)
Ni idam chutti porul villaku (Spot my parts and explain it
to me)
- - Mayya Mayya From Guru. Penned by Vairamuthu.
I need not state the obvious similarity between the
2 different songs. We had such songs all this while. So what is worrying now? Why
this concern now? In those times, we had one such song in a film. And one such
film was released among 50 other films. Now, we have 50 such songs being
released in less than 10 films. Therefore, the impact is severe. More
devastating than what we could ever imagine, considering the latest incidents
against young women. We all know the crucial role tamil films and songs have
played in these violent incidents. If tamil cinema isn’t an influence on the
impressionable teenagers, how would you explain the strong objections against
Rajinikanth’s cigarette-smoking style in films? Why did Ministers have to
interfere, beg, plead and request him to stop smoking in films?
Such is the impact of Tamil cinema on people. When they see
it, they follow it. Absolutely blindly.
Lyricist Vairamuthu himself, in an interview, mentioned that
there is a difference between vulgarity and sensuality.
Definitely, there should be and there was a thin line between these 2 concepts.
Another song:
Definitely, there should be and there was a thin line between these 2 concepts.
Another song:
Maanga Maanga Rendu Maanga (2 mangoes)
Market-ku pogatha kundu maanga (The huge mango that has not gone to the market)
-
- -Maanga From the film, Prathap
Penne Unathu Mellidai Paarten
(Lady, I saw your slender hips)
Adadaa Brahman Kanjanadi (Oh God,
He is a miser)
Satrae Nimirndaen Thalai Sutri
Ponen (I raised my head, I was stunned)
Aahaa Avane Vallaladi. (Oh my god,
He isn’t actually one)
-Anbe Anbe From the film Jeans.
Both songs are referring to women’s breasts. One is vulgarity. The other isn’t.
Ironically, both are written by
Vairamuthu. But why was this thin line blurred, sir? What was the need for
someone to describe a woman in vulgar terms? It was a matter of choice. You
chose it to be that way and it ended up in that way you portrayed it to be. The
thin line, that should have been well-guarded, is gone. The song became a hit!
Now every tom dick harry dhanush simbu gv Prakash are
composing songs in the way they want it. And all these songs have all kinds of
garbage in them. Sighs.
I have become emotionally tired of asking this question myriad times- Shouldn't cinema be a medium to bring a change in our society rather than keep re-instilling derogatory and regressive values prevalent since the dark ages?
I have become emotionally tired of asking this question myriad times- Shouldn't cinema be a medium to bring a change in our society rather than keep re-instilling derogatory and regressive values prevalent since the dark ages?
No. absolutely not a bit. Because I have sense. I know this is filth. I ignore them. I don’t endorse them. I don’t go around looking at half-naked men at the swimming pool or something, humming “arjuna arjuna” song (a song in which sarathkumar appears shirtless for a good 30 seconds of the song) That will never happen.
And I hope, man with sense, possibly the very few gentlemen existing
on earth would continue to stay against such atrocities found in Tamil cinema
and songs.
I just listened to the thirunaal song. The song merely says - Humans are prone to get angry; during heated conversations there are so many words other than prostitute that may be used. But, even under he worst circumstances do not use the "prostitute" word.
ReplyDeleteAnd as for the jeans song; he'd described the body without using so called vulgar words. I would like to know why you would think that it's derogatory .